|
JOURNAL
OF
SPORTS SCIENCE &
MEDICINE
|
|
Research
article
|
IMPROVING FUNCTIONAL PERFORMANCE AND MUSCLE POWER 4-TO-6 MONTHS AFTER ANTERIOR CRUCIATE LIGAMENT RECONSTRUCTION |
|||||||||
Sabrine Souissi1,6, Del P. Wong2 ,
Alexandre Dellal1,3,7, Jean-Louis
Croisier4, Zied Ellouze5 and
Karim Chamari1,6 |
|||||||||
1Tunisian Research Laboratory ''Sport Performance Optimisation'' - National Centre of Medicine and Science in Sport (CNMSS) - El Menzah, Tunisia, 2Department of Health and Physical Education, The Hong Kong Institute of Education, Hong Kong, 3Olympique Lyonnais FC (soccer), 4Department of Motricity Sciences, Liège, Belgium, 5Aspetar-Orthopeadic and Sports Medicine Hospital, Doha, Qatar, 6ISSEP, Ksar-Saïd, University of Manouba, Tunisia, 7Santy Orthopedicae Clinical, Sport Science and Research Department, Lyon, France |
|||||||||
|
|||||||||
© Journal of Sports Science and Medicine (2011) 10, 655 - 664 |
|||||||||
|
|
| ABSTRACT | |||||||||||||
| The purpose of this study was to examine the effects of 8-week
retraining programs, with either two or three training sessions per week,
on measures of functional performance and muscular power in athletes with
anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR). Sixteen male athletes
were randomly assigned to two groups after ACLR: a functional training group
(FTG, n = 8) training 2 intense sessions per week (4hrs/week), and a control
group (CG, n = 8) training 3 sessions per week with moderate intensity (6hrs/week).
The two groups were assessed at four and six months post-ACLR and the effects
of retraining were measured using the following assessments: the functional
and the muscular power tests, and the agility T-test. After retraining,
the FTG had improved more than the CG in the operated leg in the single
leg hop test (+34.64% vs. +10.92%; large effect), the five jump test (+8.87%
vs. +5.03%; medium effect), and single leg triple jump (+32.15% vs. +16.05%;
medium effect). For the agility T-test, the FTG had larger improvements
(+17.26% vs. +13.03%, medium effect) as compared to the CG. For the bilateral
power tests, no significant training effects were shown for the two groups
in the squat jump (SJ), the counter movement jump (CMJ) and the free arms
CMJ (Arm CMJ). On the other hand, the unilateral CMJ test with the injured
and the uninjured legs showed a significant increase for the FTG with respect
to CG (p < 0.05). The present study introduces a new training modality
in rehabilitation after ACLR that results in good recovery of the operated
limb along with the contra-lateral leg. This may allow the athletes to reach
good functional and strength performance with only two physical training
sessions per week, better preparing them for a return to sport activity
at 6 months post- ACLR and eventually sparing time for a possible progressive
introduction of the sport specific technical training. Key words: ACL reconstruction, knee injury, retraining, agility, strength testing, power testing. |
|
| INTRODUCTION | |||||||||||||
|
Anterior
cruciate ligament (ACL) rupture is a serious knee injury sustained by
athletes during sport and leisure time activities. The risk of ACL injury
is significantly greater in individuals during pivoting and cutting movements
(Dye et al., 1998).
Athletes often find it difficult to return to full function after injuring
the ACL, and frequently surgery is carried out to re-establish joint stability.
However, it has been suggested that, after surgery the ability to perform
functional activities and balance may be decreased (Noyes et al., 1991),
and deficits have been reported in the muscular and sensory processes
after reconstructive surgery (Ben Moussa et al., 2008;
Legnani et al., 2010).
|
|
| METHODS | |||||||||||||
|
Subjects Functional
tests Muscular
power test Statistical
analysis |
|
| RESULTS | |||||||||||||
|
The statistical power of the present study was 0.85. The reliability
(ICC) of the following tests: the horizontal jump tests- forward hop tests-
(SLH, SL3H, and 5JT), the vertical jump tests (SJ, CMJ, Arm CMJ, CMJI,
CMJNI), and the agility "T" test was excellent (Table
4). |
|
| DISCUSSION | |||||||||||||
|
The present study showed that from the 4th to 6th
months post-surgery, the functional training program resulted in significantly
greater improvements than the standardized rehabilitation program concerning
the functional tests (the SLH injured, the SLH uninjured and the 5JT with
injured leg), the CMJ with one leg, and the agility "T" test
performance. |
|
| AUTHORS BIOGRAPHY | |
| Sabrine SOUISSI Employment: PhD student working in the field of rehabilitation. Sport and Physical Education teacher. Degrees: Master in Exercise Science Research interests: Functional training after Injuries E-mail: sabrinesss@yahoo.fr |
|
| Del P. WONG Employment: Assistant professor, Department of Health and Physical Education, The Hong Kong Institute of Education, Hong Kong Degrees: DPhil Research interests: elite sport performance, football science, sport physiology E-mail: delwong@alumni.cuhk.net |
|
| Alexandre DELLAL Employment: Fitness coach and headchief of science and research in Olympique Lyonnais FC (Soccer) Degrees: PhD Research interests: Training in soccer, match-analysis, small-sided games, injury in soccer E-mail: alexandredellal@gmail.com |
|
| Jean-Louis CROISIER Employment: Professor and Head of the Department of Motricity Sciences (University of Liege, Belgium Degrees: MD Research interests: Isokinetic evaluation-Motricity sciences E-mail: jlcroisier@ulg.ac.be |
|
| Zied ELLOUZE Employment: Doctor specialist in Rehabilitation and Physical Medicine Degrees: MD Research interests: Rehabilitation and Functional Training after sport injuries E-mail: zied.ellouze@aspetar.com |
|
| Karim CHAMARI Employment: Doctor in Exercise PhysiologyHead of the Research Lab `Sport Performance Optimisation` National Centre of Medicine and Science in Sport.Active researcher in football and sport science.Fitness coach in professional soccer clubs Degrees: PhD Research interests: Physiology of Soccer - Physical capacities evaluation – Training E-mail: karimchamari@gmx.net |
|